Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit January 16, 1996, 95-5086 (Roger Pilon v. United States Department of Justice)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-01-1996
*1112
WALD, Circuit Judge:
This is a case about the meaning of “disclose,” as that term is used in the Privacy Act of 1974. In particular, we consider under what circumstances Congress intended that “disclose” encompass the dissemination of a document to someone who is already familiar with it. The district court granted appellee Department of Justice summary judgment in this Privacy Act suit, reasoning that the agency’s unauthorized release of a protected record to one of its former employees was not a disclosure because the recipient was already familiar with the document from his time in government service. We reverse. While this court interpreted “disclose” in
Hollis v. United States Department of the Army,
856 F.2d 1541 (D.C.Cir.1988), not to include the dissemination by an agency of a protected document to one who had already legitimately been given the same information by the agency, we now decline to extend
Hollis
beyond the limited factual circumstances that gave rise to it.
Hollis,
read contextually, does not sanction the unauthorized release of protected records to former agency employees, and to extend its reasoning to the facts of this case would create a gaping hole in the protective orbit of the Privacy Act. Accordingly, we hold that the Department’s transmission of a protected record in this case to its former employee constituted a disclosure. As a separate matter, even were we to adopt the more limited construction of “disclose” applied in
Hollis
in this case, we would still conclude that summary judgment was not appropriate because the Department did not present sufficient evidence that the former employee in fact remembered the document’s material contents in detail at the time it was sent to him.
I. Background
A.
The Privacy Act and
Hollis’
Interpretation of “Disclose”
The Privacy Act of 1974 (“the Act”) establishes conditions under which certain kinds of agency documents must be kept private and may be disclosed only to authorized individuals.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit