Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit January 29, 1996, 736, Docket 95-2415 (1-95-Cv-553-P1 v. 1-95-Cv-553-D1, 1-95-Cv-553-D2, 1-95-Cv-553-D3, 1-95-Cv-553-D4)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-01-1996

JON O. NEWMAN, Chief Judge:

This appeal concerns a criminal defendant’s effort to seek redress for an undisputed breach of an unusual provision of a plea agreement — a provision committing the United States to have the FBI investigate allegations of corruption at a state prison. The defendant, identified in the case caption as “PI” to protect his identity from disclosure, appeals from the June 15, 1995, judgment of the District Court for the Eastern District of New York (Eugene H. Nickerson, Judge)

*136

dismissing Ms complaint for failure to state a claim on wMch relief may be granted. Judge Nickerson ruled that monetary damages were not available and that no claim for specific performance was being asserted. We agree with the first ruling, but disagree with the second, and therefore reverse and remand for further proceedings.

Background

Appellant is serving a state sentence in federal custody, since he is currently in the Government’s witness protection program. During a federal investigation of obstruction of justice offenses, appellant entered into a plea agreement with the UMted States Attorney for the Eastern District of New York. Appellant agreed to plead guilty to one count of obstruction of justice and to assist the Government in the prosecution of others involved in the obstruction offenses. The UMted States Attorney agreed to various provisions relating to the non-prosecution of other offenses and to certain Sentencing Guidelines calculations concerMng the obstruction offense. Pertinent to the pending appeal, paragraph six of the plea agreement provides that “the FBI has agreed to investigate allegations of corruption at the Sing Sing [N.Y.] Correctional Facility relating to the defendant’s [now, plaintiffs] claim that employees of the Sing Sing Correctional Facility were engaged in the unlawful sale of foodstuffs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.