Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit May 29, 1996, 94-5811, 94-5911 (Carrington South Health Care Center, Inc., Petitioner/cross-Respondent v. National Labor Relations Board, Respondent/cross-Petitioner)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-05-1996

CLELAND, District Judge.

Employees at Petitioner’s nursing home voted to unionize, and Petitioner filed objections to the union’s campaign methods with NLRB’s Regional Director, asserting that the methods included racially inflammatory appeals. The Regional Director conducted an investigation, but conducted no hearing before overruling Petitioner’s objections and certifying the union. The NLRB refused to review the Regional Director’s decision, determining that Petitioner “raised no substantial issue warranting review.” Petitioner subsequently declined the union’s overtures to bargain, and the NLRB ordered Petitioner to cease and desist from refusing to bargain. Petitioner seeks an evidentiary hearing on its objections while the NLRB seeks enforcement of its order. We must determine whether a substantial and material factual issue existed with respect to the Petitioner’s complaint. Because we find that factual issues exist, we remand the case for a hearing and refuse enforcement of NLRB’s order.

I.

Petitioner maintains that the union sought unlawfully to arouse and exploit racial feelings among the minorities in the voting unit. Specifically, Petitioner objects to three cartoons and one quote that appeared in some of the twenty-three handbills the union published over the course of the campaign.

The first cartoon, appearing in the April 28, 1993 handbill, shows a white man flipping a coin and saying “I’ll take a dozen” while a group of workers looks on. Although the racial composition of the group in the drawing cannot be determined with certainty, many of the workers are clearly intended to appear black. The second cartoon appeared in the May 10 handbill, and depicts a group of people laboring to pull a wagon, in which are a woman in a chair, a man at the rear holding something like a portable radio and a person at the front of the wagon brandishing a whip. The caption has the man with the whip saying “You are employed at my Will!!!

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.