Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit May 8, 1996, 95-7161 (Finegold, Alexander + Associates, Inc. v. Setty & Associates, Ltd.)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-05-1996

RANDOLPH, Circuit Judge:

In February 1990, the predecessor firm of Finegold, Alexander + Associates, Inc., a Massachusetts corporation, contracted with the General Services Administration to provide architectural and engineering services for the renovation of the Veterans Administration Building in Washington, D.C. Eight months later, Setty & Associates, Ltd., a Virginia corporation, entered into a subeon-

*207

tract with Finegold to provide mechanical and electrical designs for the project. During the course of the work, the government project officer requested several changes that required Setty to revise its designs. Setty submitted a certified claim in Fine-gold’s name to GSA for additional compensation for the work required by these changes. GSA opposed the claim on the ground of “accord and satisfaction,” arguing that Fine-gold had already agreed to thé amount of increased compensation GSA would pay for the additional work. The Contracting Officer denied the claim, and Setty’s administrative appeal, prosecuted in Finegold’s name, was subsequently dismissed for lack of prosecution after Finegold refused to finance the litigation.

Setty then filed a demand for arbitration before the American Arbitration Association seeking damages from Finegold. In a series of twelve claims, Setty alleged that Finegold had violated the subcontract by failing to provide timely and accurate information, failing to present Setty’s request for equitable adjustment to GSA, and failing to distribute to Setty an equitable share of the additional compensation it had received from GSA After considering briefs submitted by the parties, the arbitrators appointed to hear the case concluded that the matter was arbitra-ble. Finegold filed suit in D.C. Superior Court to stay the arbitration proceedings. Setty removed the case to federal district court, alleging diversity of citizenship.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.