Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit May 24, 1996, 95-20063 (United States v. Pierre S. Tanios)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-05-1996

POLITZ, Chief Judge:

The opinion rendered herein on March 8, 1996 is withdrawn and the following is substituted in its place.

Convicted of conspiracy to evade federal fuel excise taxes,

1

Pierre S. Tanios appeals, urging insufficiency of the evidence; error in the jury charge, both before and dining deliberations; and impropriety in the jury’s disclosure of its division when communicating its deadlock to the court. Finding no reversible error, we affirm.

Background

The indictment arose out of Tamos’ business relationship with Lion Boulus, who also was named in the conspiracy count and in the five substantive counts of the indictment. The evidence establishes that Boulus, using the assumed name Adolphe Moussa,

2

formed Moussco Investment, Inc., which operated as a wholesale distributor of diesel fuel, purchasing from a supplier and reselling to retail outlets. During the relevant period herein payment of the excise tax was the responsibility of the wholesale distributors like Moussco, with tax liability attaching

*100

upon sale to a retailer.

3

Moussco’s tax accountability exceeded $250,000.

The evidence reflects that Tanios, also known as “Pierre Torres,” was owner of several of the retail outlets serving as Moussco’s customers. He had a long-standing personal and business relationship with Boulus. He often represented Moussco, doing such things as having a supplier make invoices to a convenience store in the name of Moussco, making payments to Moussco’s suppliers and creditors for the fuel delivered, and writing checks in Moussco’s name.

The jury found Boulus guilty on all counts but, initially, it could not agree on a verdict for Tanios. Contrary to the trial judge’s express instructions, in a written communication with the court the jury informed that it had reached an impasse with ten voting to convict and two voting to acquit. The court did not disclose this division to the parties but gave the jury a modified

Allen

charge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.