Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit August 30, 1996, 95-55161 (Ruth Lopez v. City of Needles, Ca, a Municipal Corporation Leon Berger William Cetti Roy Mills Flora Hill Leroy Morgan)
Also known as
United States · · · 30-08-1996
O’SCANNLAIN, Circuit Judge:
We must decide whether an order dismissing a complaint without prejudice may be treated as an appealable final decision when the plaintiff fails to notify the district court of her intention to stand on the dismissed complaint.
I
At an October 4,1993 meeting of the Needles City Council, Council member Ruth Lopez announced that she had been informed of possible hazardous waste dumping in the City of Needles sewer treatment plant.
1
Lopez was asked to identify the source of her knowledge of the allegedly illegal dumping, but refused to do so.
After the City Manager filed a police report asserting that Lopez had announced the existence of hazardous waste dumping into the City of Needles sewer treatment plant, sheriff Leroy Morgan questioned Lopez at her home. The sheriff requested that she divulge her sources to him, but Lopez refused to identify her informants.
On October 15, 1993, the City held a special “Board of Inquiry” meeting. Lopez was subpoenaed to testify in a second Board of Inquiry meeting held on October 20, 1993, at which City Council members and Deputy City Attorney Michael Andelson questioned her. Lopez refused to name her sources and insisted that she had never asserted hazardous waste dumping existed, only that dumping existed. Lopez was also subpoenaed for an October 25, 1993 meeting, at which she again refused to disclose her informants. The City Council voted to prosecute her for violating the city charter by refusing to answer City Council inquiries and interfering with city administration. The City Council also voted to prosecute her civilly for contempt of court.
The civil contempt action began on November 10, 1993, in state superior court, pursuant to Cal. Gov’t Code § 37106 which requires a mayor to report to superior court the refusal of a subpoenaed person to testify before a legislative body.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit