Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit October 9, 1996, 94-2220, 94-2224 (K & T Enterprises, Inc., D/B/A Dairy Queen of Blissfield, and Tahani Khoury v. Zurich Insurance Company, Cross-Appellee)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-10-1996

BOGGS, Circuit Judge.

When is fire not the enemy of ice? When the 50% shareholder of a failing Dairy Queen franchise in Blissfield, Michigan torches that franchise outlet for profit, and his wife, who also owns 50% of the franchise, is still permitted by a district court upon a jury verdict to collect fire insurance proceeds for the damage caused by the arson. We reverse this decision, which, if left to stand, would encourage individuals to use the corporate veil to perpetrate insurance fraud.

1

I

Kareem and Tahani Khoury, husband and wife, purchased real estate in Blissfield upon which they built a Dairy Queen franchise incorporated as K & T Enterprises (“K & T”), with each of them holding half of the stock. To finance their business, they borrowed from the Society Bank, Michigan (“Society Bank”) and granted the bank a mortgage on the property. Kareem was the president and sole officer. He worked in the cooking area of the Dairy Queen. He also kept the books and performed most management tasks, such as writing checks and negotiating with banks and lessors, while Tahani worked in the front of the store, decorating ice cream cakes and supervising the employees there.

*173

The Khourys obtained fire insurance for K & T from the Zurich Insurance Company (“Zurich”). The policy named K & T as the insured party. Two parts of that insurance policy are particularly relevant to this case. The first provided that the policy is void in any case of misrepresentation by K & T, either before the insurance contract was signed or after, and the second provided that no loss or damage claim would be paid out if losses or damage resulted from a dishonest or criminal act that K & T committed, whether acting alone or in collusion with other persons.

The Khourys’ Dairy Queen opened in July of 1989 and quickly began to fail. Blissfield is a town with a population of only 2,550, but has 10 restaurants, including one next door to the Dairy Queen. Moreover, an ice cream parlor is nearby.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.