District Court of Appeal of Florida April 10, 1996, Nos. 94-1878, 94-2675 (Little Bridge Marina, Inc. v. Jones Boat Yard, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-1996
PER CURIAM.
This is an appeal by the plaintiff, Little Bridge Marina, Inc. (hereinafter “Little Bridge”) from an adverse final judgment in a breach of contract action. The jury verdict denied the plaintiffs claim for breach of contract and held in favor of the defendant, Jones Boat Yard, Inc. (hereinafter “Boat Yard”) for its counterclaim for breach of contract. For the following reasons, we reverse the final judgment and remand for a new trial.
Eric Gustinger and Alfred Gustinger, Jr. (hereinafter “the Gustingers”) are the owners and officers of Little Bridge, a small corporation formed to operate a marina. In the late 1980s, Little Bridge bought a sixty-seven foot sailing vessel with the intention of using it as a charter boat at the marina. After spending two years restoring the boat, the Gustingers took the vessel to the Boat Yard for repairs to the boat, which also included sandblasting and painting the bottom and topsides of the vessel.
The repair work performed by Boat Yard was unsatisfactory to the Gustingers. After several phone calls and letters to Calvin Kreidt, the Boat Yard foreman, disputing the bill and requesting additional repairs, Little Bridge filed a breach of • contract action against the Boat Yard. The Boat Yard counterclaimed for breach of contract and filed an answer denying most of the allegations in the complaint.
Since each party disputed the facts upon which the case was based, the trial centered around a question of credibility of the main witnesses for each side. As a consequence, the appellant contends that the trial court erred in allowing defense counsel to undermine the credibility of its main witness during cross-examination by improperly impeaching the witness, Alfred Gustinger, Jr., about his career as a criminal defense attorney. At trial, the following exchange occurred during Mr. Gustinger’s cross-examination:
MR. MCCORMACK [defense counsel]:
Are you an attorney?
WITNESS [Alfred Gustinger, Jr.]: Yes, I am.
*79MR.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit