District Court of Appeal of Florida April 10, 1996, No. 95-02417 (Hobbs v. Kearney)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-04-1996
CAMPBELL, Acting Chief Judge.
Appellant, Helen Miller Hobbs, challenges the final declaratory judgment which concluded that appellee, Grace E. Kearney, held a perpetual easement over appellant’s property. The final judgment interpreted the easement to implicitly grant to Kearney, in perpetuity, the right to construct or use a later-constructed boat dock at the eastern end of the easement into the waters of Lemon Bay. We reverse the final judgment insofar as it found an implicit perpetual easement to use or construct a boat dock.
On April 29, 1977, Kearney and Hobbs entered into a contract in which Kearney was to purchase from Hobbs a Gulf-front residence on Manasota Key. Access to Manaso-ta Key and to the properties involved is by means of a county road. The county road runs between the Gulf-front property being purchased by Kearney that lies west of the road and property east of the road being retained by Hobbs. Lemon Bay forms the eastern boundary of the property retained by Hobbs. Before entering into the contract of sale, Kearney informed Hobbs of Kearney’s desire to purchase Gulf-front property with an access to a dock for keeping a boat on the Lemon Bay side of the “Island” (Manasota Key). The contract of sale provided that Kearney’s purchase of the Gulf-front property would include “an easement across the South 3 feet of the Seller’s property running from the County Road East to the waters of Lemon Bay....” On May 25, 1977, Hobbs wrote Kearney the following letter:
Dear Mrs. Kearney:
This is to advise that pursuant to our oral agreement concerning the walking easement, boat dock and docking facilities, we agree to the following:
a. A three-foot walking easement over the South portion of my property on the Lemon Bay side shall be an easement contained in the deed, and therefore actually part of the transaction.
b.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit