Supreme Court of Alabama February 23, 1996, 1941703 (Ex Parte N.P.)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-02-1996
HOUSTON, Justice.
We granted certiorari review in order to consider the single issue whether the Court of Civil Appeals erred in upholding the trial court’s demal of N.P.’s motion for a new trial of her loss of consortium claim against the defendant, Dr. Josiah Reed.
Factual Background
In 1985, N.P.’s husband, K.P., was referred to Dr. Reed for the treatment of Peyrome’s disease. This disease causes pain and disfigurement to the penis. Dr. Reed recommended surgery to correct this condition. It was undisputed that the recommended procedure was very risky and that in some eases PeyroMe’s disease improves markedly without surgery, given time.
On March 31, 1986, Dr. Reed performed surgery on the husband to attempt to correct the condition. After the surgery, Dr. Reed applied an “elastoplast” pressure dressing, which was left on for 45 hours. After the dressmg was removed, most of the husband’s perns tissue turned black and had to be removed.
The evidence clearly showed that the husband went through tremendous pam and mental angrnsh, as a result of the unsuccessful procedure. Dr. Reed does not dispute that since the surgery the husband has never been physically able to have intercourse with the wife. The husband eventually underwent two reconstructive surgeries m a failed attempt to restore sexual function. There was also uncontradicted evidence that before the initial surgery, even up to the mght before it, N.P. and her husband were still able to have intercourse, although the husband’s Peyro-Me’s disease was making mtercourse increasingly painful for him.
Since the surgery, because of the husband’s embarrassment caused by Ms physical condition and because of N.P.’s desire not to *930make him feel sexually inadequate, N.P. and her husband no longer share the same bed. N.P.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit