Supreme Court of Alabama January 26, 1996, 1950086 (State ex rel. Mosley v. Mosley)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-01-1996

HOUSTON, Justice.

The Alabama Department of Human Resources (“the State”), on behalf of Martha Jane Horton,1 petitioned the Marshall County Circuit Court to hold Horton’s former husband, Allen Ricky Mosley, in contempt of court for failing to pay a portion of his minor *107child’s dental expenses. Horton and Mosley’s divorce judgment required Mosley to pay half of the child’s dental expenses not covered by Mosley’s medical insurance.2 Mosley, acting pro se, responded by denying the allegations and demanding “strict proof thereof.” At the hearing on the petition, the State established through Horton’s testimony that she either had paid, or had contractually obligated herself to pay, for dental work for the child; that the dental work was medically necessary and was ongoing; and that Mosley had failed to contribute his share. Mosley, representing himself at the hearing, testified that he was financially unable to pay for half of the child’s dental work. At no time, either before or during the hearing, did he request that the divorce judgment be modified so as to reduce his obligation to pay half of his child’s dental expenses. The trial court, not finding Mosley in contempt, modified the divorce judgment by making Mosley responsible for one-third of the cost of the dental treatment for the minor child.

The State moved for a new trial, arguing that the trial court’s order was contrary to the applicable law and that it addressed an issue not raised by the pleadings. The trial court denied the motion, stating in part:

“The trial in this matter was regarding issues of contempt of court and [Mosley’s] oral defense that he was unable to pay the [previously] ordered dental expenses and that [Horton] refused repeatedly to give him any information regarding dental treatment of the parties’ son. [Mosley’s] oral request complied with [Roberson v. Roberson, 558 So.2d 946 (Ala.Civ.App. 1990) ].

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.