District Court of Appeal of Florida August 30, 1996, No. 95-2763 (Starita v. West Putnam Post Number 10164, Veterans of Foreign Wars of the United States, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-08-1996

COBB, Judge.

The sole issue on this appeal is whether the trial court erred in granting Post 10164’s motion to transfer venue from Putnam County to Marion County.

On November 29,1994, Gloria Starita1 filed a complaint against Post 10164 and Virginia Mullins, Kathleen Freaney and David Rye.2 The action was brought pursuant to section 768.16, Florida Statutes (1991). Mullins was a permanent bar manager for the VFW and Freaney was a bartender.3

According to the complaint, on November 28,1992, VFW Post 10164 (located in Putnam County) served Gerald Conrad alcoholic beverages and later, while he was operating a motor vehicle in Marion County, he collided with Mary Jade Brown causing her death. Starita claimed that the defendants “knew, or had reason to know, that [Conrad] was habitually addicted to the use of alcoholic beverages” and that at the time in question knew or had reason to know he was “drunk or intoxicated in direct violation of section 768.125, Florida Statutes (1991).”

On June 13,1995, Post 10164 filed a motion to transfer venue from Putnam to Marion County pursuant to section 47.122, Florida Statutes. In support, Post 10164 alleged that Starita had filed an identical action in Marion County during which hearings and discovery occurred. Additionally, Post 10164 pointed out that Judge Angel from Marion County was familiar with the case and that Starita was “forum shopping.” Finally, Post *52210164 maintained that trying the case in Marion rather than Putnam would not be inconvenient for the witnesses or parties.

Starita countered that section 47.122 only allowed a venue change where the movant could demonstrate a substantial inconvenience/undue expense or where the forum chosen by the plaintiff would not afford a fair and impartial decision. Starita maintained that neither reason was established by Post 10164.

On September 20,1995, the court rendered an order granting Post 10164⅛ motion to transfer venue from Putnam to Marion County:

...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.