New Jersey Tax Court April 1, 1996 (Livingston Mall Corp. v. Livingston Township)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-04-1996

CRABTREE, J.T.C.

This is a local property tax case wherein plaintiff seeks direct review of the 1991, 1992 and 1993 assessments on its property located at 112 Eisenhower Parkway, Livingston, New Jersey (Block 290, Lot 5). The assessments, the same for all years, were:

*508Land $5,364,000

Improvements 40,947,100

Total $46,311,100

The subject of the controversy is a super-regional mall1 containing a gross building area of 1,144,723 square feet. The building is divided into the following components:

R.H. Mac/s (anchor store)2 255,061 sq. ft.

Sears (anchor store) 191,921 sq. ft.

Lord & Taylor (anchor store) 169,140 sq. ft.

130+ mall retail stores 375,221 sq. ft.

Kiosks 3,380 sq. ft.

Common area 150,000 sq. ft.

The anchor stores are all owner-occupied, except that plaintiff owns the land and leases it to the anchor stores.

The mall building is situated on 59.6 acres of land.

The entire land area, except for the area occupied by the mall building, is a parking area with 5,499 parking spaces. In addition, the mall enjoys an easement over 9.54 acres owned by Public Service Electric and Gas (PSE & G). This acreage lies between the mall land and Eisenhower Parkway. The easement provides for ingress and egress from the highway; it also provides additional parking, driveways, lighting, telephone conduits, a storm and sewer drainage system, and public utility lines for water, sewer, gas, electric and telephone lines. The mall could not function without the easement.

*509The mall area occupied by the Lord & Taylor anchor store was previously occupied by a Hahne’s anchor store. The latter closed its doors in 1989, and the area theretofore occupied by Hahne’s was closed while renovations were made to permit occupancy by Lord & Taylor. This renovation continued throughout 1989.

Extensive renovations were also made to the mall in 1991.

There are thirteen kiosks, eight of them permanent, five seasonal. All kiosks are on rollers.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.