Wyoming Supreme Court December 22, 1997, 96-226 (Sheridan Retirement Partners v. City of Sheridan)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-12-1997

TAYLOR, Chief Justice.

Appellant, Sheridan Retirement Partners (Sheridan Partners), filed a declaratory judgment action claiming that appellee, City of Sheridan, improperly assessed plan investment fees for a retirement home project. The district court found that the lawsuit was actually a request for review of an agency action and, as such, was not timely filed within thirty days after notice of the final agency decision. Accordingly, the district court dismissed the action for lack of subject matter jurisdiction. We agree with the district court’s finding regarding the nature and timeliness of the claim and, therefore, dismiss this appeal.

I. ISSUES

Sheridan Partners presents a single issue for review:

Whether the district court erroneously concluded that appellant should have sought judicial review of the June 21,1993 City Council decision upholding the assessment against appellant for plant investment fees.

The City of Sheridan responds:

The District Court did not err in finding Appellant’s complaint for declaratory relief should have been brought as a petition for review and that the court was without jurisdiction due to Appellant’s failure to timely request the same.

Appellant did not demonstrate a justiciable controversy under

Brimmer v. Thompson

for the District Court to proceed under the Declaratory Judgment Statute, W.S. § 1-37-103.

II. FACTS

In 1993, Sheridan Partners planned to build and operate an assisted living facility in Sheridan, Wyoming. The plans were submitted to the City of Sheridan for review, comment and fee assessments. The Building Inspector/Plans Examiner (Plans Examiner) assessed a fee total, which included “plant investment fees,” based on classification of the project as a multiple family dwelling pursuant to Municipal Code §§ 28-4.4,28-4.5 and 28-4.6.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.