District Court, D. New Hampshire May 14, 1997, CV-96-293-SD (Metrop. Prop. & Cas. Ins. v. Daigle)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-05-1997

Metrop. Prop. & Cas. Ins. v. Daigle CV-96-293-SD 05/14/97

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE

DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE

Metropolitan Property & Casualty

Insurance Company;

Allstate Insurance Company

v. Civil No. 96-293-SD

Richard Daigle;

Irene Palmer;

Donald Palmer

David Smith

O R D E R

In its order of March 27, 1997, this court ruled that

Metropolitan Property & Casualty Insurance Company had no

contractual obligation to indemnify their insured, Richard

Daigle, for threatened legal liability arising from a civil

action brought against Daigle by Irene Palmer for the results of

a staged arrest. Under the insurance policy. Metropolitan was

obligated to indemnify Daigle for legal liability arising from an

"occurrence" or an "accident." Under caselaw construction of

similar policy language, liability-producing conduct is not

accidental if it is inherently injurious, which means that the

conduct is certain to result in some injury. Vermont Mutual Ins.

Co. v. Malcolm, 128 N.H. 521, 523 (1986) . While courts had not

previously elaborated on the definition of "injury," this court

drew from the distinction between "injury" and "harm" in the

R estatement (S e c o n d ) of Torts § 7 cmt. a (1965) . Under the Restatement

definition, "injury" denotes invasion of a legally protected

interest, while "harm" denotes loss in fact, and the two concepts

are not co-terminus. Relying on this definition of injury, the

court held that the staged arrest perpetrated by Daigle was

inherently injuries (and thus not a covered "accident") because

it was certain to result in invasion of Palmer's legally

protected interest in freedom from restraint, even though no harm

or loss in fact was certain to attend that challenged conduct.

Daigle urges reconsideration on grounds that this court

misinterpreted the term "injury" for purposes of determining

whether conduct is inherently injurious.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.