Colorado Court of Appeals October 23, 1997, 96CA1642 (Feeney v. American West Airlines)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-10-1997
Opinion by
Judge METZGER.
In this dispute over lost baggage, plaintiffs, Jonathan C. and Deborah Feeney, appeal the summary judgment entered in favor of defendant, America West Airlines. Because we conclude the provisions of the Warsaw Convention are applicable and bar plaintiffs’ claim, we affirm.
Plaintiffs purchased round-trip tickets for travel from Denver to Cabo San Lucas, Mexico, via Phoenix, Arizona. Before their return trip from Cabo San Lucas, they checked seven bags with Aero California, the carrier which had transported them between Cabo San Lucas and Phoenix, and received seven baggage claim cheeks. The airline tickets and claim cheeks provided for a stop-over in Phoenix and indicated a specific America West flight originating in Phoenix and ending in Denver.
In Phoenix, plaintiffs collected the seven bags and turned them over to America West. However, because the Aero California claim checks listed the America West flight number and showed Denver as the final destination, plaintiffs did not receive new baggage claim checks.
Upon arriving in Denver, plaintiffs received only six of their seven checked bags. They filed the appropriate claims and, after America West tendered a check for $640 for the lost bag (its maximum liability under the Warsaw Convention), plaintiffs initiated this lawsuit seeking damages of over $5,000.
The trial court granted America West’s motion for summary judgment and plaintiffs initiated this appeal.
I.
Summary judgment is a drastic remedy and is never warranted except on a clear showing that there is no genuine issue as to any material fact.
Crystal Homes, Inc. v. Radetsky,
895 P.2d 1179 (Colo.App.1995).
In the context of a summary judgment proceeding, an issue of material fact is one whose resolution will affect the outcome of the case.
Krane v. St. Anthony Hospital Systems,
738 P.2d 75 (Colo.App.1987). However, a “genuine issue” cannot be raised by counsel simply by means of argument.
Sullivan v. Davis,
172 Colo. 490, 474 P.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit