Idaho Supreme Court December 8, 1997, 23030, 23673 (Walters v. Industrial Indemnity Co. of Idaho)

Also known as

United States · · · 08-12-1997

JOHNSON, Justice.

This is a bad faith insurance case in which we consider two appeals. In the first appeal, we conclude that, following issuance of an

*837

amended remittitur from this Court, the trial court did not have jurisdiction to consider a request to amend the complaint. In the second appeal, we conclude that claim preclusion (res judicata) bars the action.

I.

THE BACKGROUND AND PRIOR PROCEEDINGS

Johnny E. Walters (Walters) suffered a work-related injury and submitted a worker’s compensation claim to Industrial Indemnity Company of Idaho (the surety). The surety denied some of Walters’s medical bills. Walters and his wife (the Walters) sued the surety and three of the surety’s employees, Chris Toshcoff, Cindy Hendrickson, and Kathleen Doty (the surety’s employees); the law firm of Quane, Smith, Howard & Hull and Alan K. Hull (the law firm); and Peter Zografos, D.C. (the doctor), alleging breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing, breach of fiduciary duty, fraud, and intentional infliction of emotional distress. In response, the surety, the surety’s employees, the law firm, and the doctor (collectively the defendants) requested the trial court to dismiss the Walters’ claims. The trial court denied the dismissal, and the defendants appealed pursuant to permission granted by this Court.

In

Walters v. Industrial Indemnity Co. of Idaho,

127 Idaho 933, 936, 908 P.2d 1240, 1243 (1996)

(Walters I),

this Court stated that the trial court should have dismissed the Walters’ claims because the trial court did not have subject matter jurisdiction to hear the case. After this Court decided

Walters I

and issued an amended remittitur, the Walters sought permission of the trial court to amend the complaint to raise constitutional claims that this Court had refused to hear in

Walters I

because the Walters had not raised those claims in the trial court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.