Court of Appeals of Washington December 16, 1997, 15664-8-III (Kimball v. Otis Elevator Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-12-1997
Schultheis, A.C.J.
Allison Kimball claims she hurt her back when she stepped out of an elevator—manufactured, installed and maintained by Otis Elevator Company—that had stopped about six inches above floor level. After a jury found the elevator was neither negligently designed nor negligently maintained, the court entered judgment in favor of Otis. Ms. Kimball contends the court (1) should not have limited evidence of misleveling solely to the injury-causing elevator, which was one in a group of five identical elevators; (2) should not have admitted a deposition that did not comply with CR 32(a)(5)(B); (3) should have summarily ruled that Otis is a common carrier, held to a higher standard of care; (4) should have instructed the jury on the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur; (5) should have declared a mistrial when defense counsel, during closing argument, mentioned the lack of evidence that the other four elevators had misleveled; and (6) should not have allowed evidence that Ms. Kimball suffered from a neuromuscular disorder affecting her shoulders. We affirm.
Ms. Kimball was employed as a phlebotomist at Sacred Heart Medical Center (SHMC) from December 1989 until October 1992. Five public elevators located near the main lobby transport members of the public and hospital staff from one floor to another. On the evening of April 29, 1991,
*172
Ms. Kimball boarded elevator 2 on the ninth floor and pushed the button for the second floor, so that she could deliver a freshly drawn blood sample to the blood bank. Carrying her tray in front of her, she faced the door and watched the floor numbers as the elevator descended. When the indicator for the second floor lit up and the doors opened, she stepped out. According to Ms. Kimball, the floor was not where she expected it to be, level with the elevator, but was lower. The unexpected step down jolted her, causing her knees to buckle. She recovered without falling, checked her tray and delivered her blood sample.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit