Court of Appeals of Washington October 24, 1997, 20254-9-II (Initiative 172 v. Western Washington Fair Ass'n)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-10-1997
Armstrong, J.
— Supporters of two initiatives sought to collect signatures at a privately owned and operated fair. The fair attempted to (1) limit the supporters to a specific area of the fairgrounds, the "free speech area,” and (2) limit the duration of the solicitation to 4 days of the 17-day event. The supporters moved for an injunction, alleging that the restriction denied them their initiative rights under the Washington Constitution. The trial court concluded that limiting the collection of signatures to the
*581
"free speech area” was a reasonable restriction, but ordered that the collection could continue for the duration of the fair. Because the supporters have not demonstrated that collecting signatures in the "free speech area” is a "substantial injury” to their initiative rights, we affirm, holding that the trial court did not abuse its discretion.
FACTS
The supporters of Initiatives 172 and 173 sought to collect signatures to qualify their measures for the 1996 general election ballot.
1
The supporters contacted the Western Washington Fair Association (Association) and requested permission to collect petition signatures during the Western Washington Fair, also known as "The Puyallup Fair” (Fair). The Association is a private, nonprofit corporation that owns the fairgrounds and operates a private fair lasting about 17 days in Puyallup, Washington. It also operates other events on the fairgrounds during the year.
In each of the past several years, more than 1.3 million people have attended the Fair. Visitors to the Fair pay admission to gain access to various arts, crafts, educational, agricultural, and livestock exhibits and displays. Under the Fair’s rules, all product sales and dissemination of information must be made from a booth display or in a specifically designated area. No roving solicitation, whether commercial, nonprofit, religious, political, or otherwise, is permitted throughout the fairgrounds.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit