Court of Appeals of Washington October 13, 1997, 37649-7-I (State v. McNeair)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-10-1997

Cox, J.

— For the first time, Michael McNeair asserts on appeal that he was denied equal protection of the laws when the trial court denied his request to be sentenced to

*334

a special drug offender sentencing alternative (DOSA). The court below denied the request on the basis that Mc-Neair was ineligible under governing statutes because he had prior felony convictions. We hold that this challenge is reviewable but that McNeair fails to show that the DOSA provision he challenges violates his right to equal protection. Accordingly, we affirm his sentence.

McNeair pleaded guilty to a charge of one count of delivery of cocaine after he was arrested in a buy-bust operation. The trial court sentenced him to a prison term of 87 months, the low end of the standard range.

After sentencing, McNeair wrote the court and requested resentencing under the DOSA. The trial judge responded by letter, informing McNeair that his prior felony convictions for VUCSA (Violation of Uniform Controlled Substances Act) disqualified him from the sentencing alternative. McNeair appeals.

I

Scope of Review

The State raises two threshold issues. They would preclude us from reaching the merits of the appeal should we agree with the State’s contentions. We reject both arguments.

The State first argues that McNeair waived his right to appeal by pleading guilty to the VUCSA charge. But this is not an appeal of his guilty plea. Rather, it is a challenge, under the Fourteenth Amendment, to the provisions of a sentencing alternative from which McNeair is excluded by the express terms of the statute.

1

In

State v.

Majors,

2

our state Supreme Court observed that while a defendant generally waives his or her right to appeal by pleading guilty, the defendant preserves the

*335

right to challenge the judgment and sentence on collateral grounds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.