Supreme Court of Georgia September 22, 1997, S97A1117 (Love v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-09-1997

Carley, Justice.

Ernest Love was tried before a jury on an indictment charging him with the malice or, in the alternative, felony murder of one victim and the commission of an aggravated assault against another victim. Under the State’s evidence, Love fired several shots at a rival gang member against whom he held a grudge. Although the shots

*485

missed Love’s intended target, one struck and killed an innocent 17-year-old bystander. On this evidence, the jury found Love guilty of the malice murder of the bystander and of a separate aggravated assault against the rival gang member. The trial court imposed sentences of life imprisonment for the murder and a 20-year term for the aggravated assault. The trial court denied Love’s motion for new trial and he appeals.

1

1. Love enumerates the general grounds, urging that there is no evidence of the victims’ “apprehension” and, thus, no evidence of his commission of an aggravated assault against either of them. A victim’s “apprehension” of receiving a violent injury is not an essential element of an assault in which it is alleged that the defendant actually attempted to commit a violent injury to the person of the victim.

Tiller v. State,

267 Ga. 888, 890 (3) (485 SE2d 720) (1997). “ ‘(I)ntentionally firing a gun at another, absent justification, is sufficient in and of itself to support a conviction of aggravated assault. [Cits.]’ [Cit.]”

Tiller v. State,

supra at 890 (3). Moreover, the State’s failure to prove the commission of an aggravated assault against the murder victim would be immaterial in any event, since Love was convicted of malice, rather than felony, murder.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.