Court of Appeals of Georgia May 22, 1997, A97A0076, A97A0124 (Smith v. Adamson)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-05-1997

Per curiam.

Case No. A97A0076

Mrs. Jimmy Smith sued judges Robert Adamson and T. Penn McWhorter, two of the three superior court judges in the Piedmont Judicial Circuit. She alleged that Judges Adamson and McWhorter

*699

should have recused themselves in prior cases involving her and her family; challenged decisions the judges made in those cases; and sought to impeach the judges, void their decisions in past cases, and enjoin them from sitting on future cases. The case was assigned to Judge T. David Motes, who dismissed the case sua sponte. The trial court then assessed a monetary sanction against Smith, and also imposed injunctive sanctions limiting Smith’s ability to file future pro se lawsuits. As we agree with the trial court that the action had to be dismissed and that the sanctions imposed were warranted, we affirm.

1. The case was properly assigned to Judge Motes, the only judge in the circuit not a defendant in the case. See Uniform Superior Court Rule 25.4. And Smith’s motion to recuse Judge Motes was properly denied without a hearing before another judge, since Smith’s supporting “affidavit,” which was not signed or notarized, was in any case legally insufficient to give rise to reasonable doubts about Judge Motes’ impartiality. See USCR 25.2 and 25.3;

In re Shafer,

215 Ga. App. 520 (451 SE2d 121) (1994);

Penney v. State,

157 Ga. App. 737 (1), 738 (2) (278 SE2d 460) (1981).

2. The sua sponte dismissal of the case was also clearly proper. See

Ga. Receivables v. Williams,

218 Ga. App. 313 (461 SE2d 280) (1995) (trial court has inherent authority to dismiss a complaint sua sponte in an appropriate case). The courtroom is not the proper forum to initiate or try impeachment proceedings. See Ga. Const. 1983, Art. Ill, Sec. VII, Pars. I

&

II. Moreover, judgments in prior actions cannot be collaterally attacked by bringing a separate action in another court. OCGA § 9-11-60.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.