District Court, N.D. Iowa January 9, 1997, C 94-3011-MWB (Mennen v. Easter Stores)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1997

MEMORANDUM OPINION ON TRIAL ON THE MERITS

TABLE OF CONTENTS

I. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND.843

II. FINDINGS OF FACT.844

III. LEGAL ANALYSIS .847

A. Mennen’s Federal Polygraph Claim.848

1. Historical background and discussion of the EPPA.849

a. Debate precipitating the enactment of the EPPA.849

b. The EPPA-General prohibition of polygraph testing.850

c. Exemptions from the EPPA.851

2. Section 2002(1) — Requiring the polygraph examination.852

3. Section 2002(2) — Using the polygraph examination results .854

4. Section 2002(3) — Discipline or discharge on the basis of test results.855

a. Discharge from his position as grocery manager.855

b. Constructive discharge.857

*843

B. Mennen’s Damages Under The EPPA .:. OO iO 00

1. Payment of lost wages and benefits. 05 LO 00

2. Damages for emotional distress. 00

3. Punitive damages. <£> 00

IV. CONCLUSION... 00 05

BENNETT, District Judge.

Competing interests of crime detection and personal privacy require the court to navigate the relatively uncharted waters of the Employee Polygraph Protection Act, 29 U.S.C. § 2001, et seq., in order to determine whether the defendant employer has violated the Act by using the plaintiffs polygraph examination results, demoting him on the basis of those results, and ultimately constructively discharging him. While working for the defendants’ grocery store, the plaintiff took a polygraph examination after he was implicated in a theft within the store. Following receipt of those results, the defendants promptly removed the plaintiff from his position as grocery manager and stripped him of his cash-handling and supervisory responsibilities. The plaintiff filed claims pursuant to federal and state polygraph statutes, asserting that the defendants used the plaintiffs examination results and took adverse employment action against him on the basis of those results.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.