Court of Appeals of Washington January 21, 1997, 14682-1-III (Cluff v. CMX Corp., Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-01-1997

Thompson, J.

Randy Cluff sued CMX Corporation for employment discrimination. The court granted CMX’s motion for summary judgment, finding Mr. Cluff failed to present a prima facie case of employment discrimination because he did not establish he had been replaced. Mr. Cluff appeals, claiming: (1) he did not need to show he had been replaced to establish a prima facie case; (2) he had been replaced by existing employees; and (3) factual issues precluded summary judgment. We affirm.

Mr. Cluff is a 45-year-old diabetic. As a result of his diabetes, he also suffers from peripheral neuropathy which

*636

necessitated amputation of his right foot and his left leg below the knee.

In 1988, Mr. Cluff began working in Yakima as a sales manager for CMX. He sold x-ray film and related products. During his employ, he increased CMX’s client base by finding new clients and persuading former clients to return to CMX.

In 1993, while Mr. Cluff was on medical leave to have his left leg amputated, CMX began restructuring in order to improve efficiency.

After surgery, Mr. Cluff received a facsimile announcing the corporate reorganization plans for eastern Washington. Yakima deliveries would occur twice a week, the Yakima receptionist position was eliminated, and three employees would cover Mr. ClufFs duties while he was on medical leave. No other changes were announced.

In April 1993, John Van Valey, CMX’s Vice President, visited Mr. Cluff in the hospital. He inquired about Mr. ClufFs condition and told Mr. Cluff he was looking forward to his return to work. Mr. Cluff later received a letter from Mr. Van Valey explaining his Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA) rights. On July 30, he learned he had been terminated. On August 6, he wrote to CMX requesting an explanation for his termination. On August 13, Mr. Van Valey wrote to Mr. Cluff and explained the termination was the result of a corporate restructuring. The Yakima sales office had closed and Mr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.