Court of Appeals of Georgia January 28, 1997, A96A2480 (Norfolk Southern Railway Co. v. Perkins)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-01-1997

Ruffin, Judge.

In this Federal Employers’ Liability Act case, Norfolk Southern Railway Company (“Norfolk Southern”) appeals from a jury verdict rendered in favor of George Perkins. Norfolk Southern contends the trial court erred in four respects: (1) denying its

Batson

motion, (2) failing to require Perkins to calculate his wage loss based on net wages minus railroad retirement taxes, (3) denying its motion for partial directed verdict relating to Perkins’ failure to prove the extent to which his prior injuries were aggravated by the incident at issue, and (4) admitting the expert opinion testimony of Perkins’ economist, Dr. Fred Johnson, despite the fact that his opinions were withheld from Norfolk Southern until the first day of trial. For reasons which follow, we affirm.

1. Norfolk Southern contends that, in violation of

Batson v. Kentucky,

476 U. S. 79 (106 SC 1712, 90 LE2d 69) (1986), the manner in which Perkins exercised peremptory challenges against white venirepersons gave rise to an inference of racial discrimination that was not successfully rebutted by Perkins. Norfolk Southern argues that Perkins used all six of his strikes against white potential jurors and that three of these strikes were used for pretextual reasons. The trial court heard argument on the

Batson

motion and ruled that Perkins presented legitimate race-neutral reasons for each of the three strikes challenged by Norfolk Southern. We agree.

“The trial court’s decision rests largely upon assessment of the [attorney’s] state of mind and credibility; it therefore lies peculiarly within a trial judge’s province. The trial court’s factual findings must be given great deference and may be disregarded only if clearly erroneous.” (Citations and punctuation omitted.)

Moak v. State,

222 Ga. App. 36, 39 (3) (473 SE2d 576) (1996). See also

Johnson v. State,

266 Ga. 775, 777 (4) (470 SE2d 637) (1996).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.