Court of Appeals of Washington April 22, 1997, 15500-5-III (Graaff v. Bakker Bros. of Idaho, Inc.)
Also known as
United States · · · 22-04-1997
Sweeney, C.J.
In 1988, Bakker Brothers of Idaho, Inc., agreed to buy Charles E. GraafFs 1989 onion seed crop. Their contract required an 85 percent germination rate. Mr. Graaff harvested the onion seed in September 1989. On October 7, 1989, the seed was received by Bakker.
On October 11, Bakker began processing Mr. GraafFs seed by running it through a screen mill and scalping process. The process consists of passing the seed through a series of screens, shakers, and fans to eliminate dirt and
*817
other unwanted material in the seed. Bakker then cleaned the seed with water and dried it.
At various points in the process, Bakker tested samples for germination. Before processing, the germination rate was 84 percent. After processing, germination rates fell to 69 percent and 67 percent on two separate samples. Because of the low germination rates, Bakker had the seed tested at several independent laboratories. That testing took place in January, February and April 1990 and produced germination rates ranging from 51 percent to 80 percent.
In January 1990, Bakker told Mr. Graaff that the seed had failed the contract germination requirements and was unmarketable. Bakker said it would not pay Mr. Graaff for the seed unless it found a buyer. It could not find a buyer. On August 14, 1990, Bakker told Mr. Graaff to pick up his seed.
In 1994, Mr. Graaff sued Bakker. Both parties moved for summary judgment. The trial court granted Bakker’s motion and dismissed Mr. GraafFs complaint. Mr. Graaff appeals.
ISSUES
We are asked to answer the following questions:
(1) Does a factual issue remain about when the germination rate should be measured—before or after processing?
(2) Did Bakker timely inspect and effectively reject the seed?
(3) Did Bakker accept the seed because its acts were inconsistent with Mr. GraafFs ownership?
DISCUSSION
Standard of Review. We review a motion for summary judgment de novo and engage in the same inquiry as the trial court.
Webstad v. Stortini,
83 Wn. App.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit