District Court, M.D. Georgia August 12, 1997, 3:94-cv-00060 (Schimmel v. Slaughter)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-08-1997

ORDER

OWENS, District Judge.

The parties in this class action have filed cross motions for summary judgment on the issue of liability only. The case has been consolidated with two other cases for resolution of that single issue (See Order of August 8, 1996 [Tab # 87]). The question before the court is whether the dunning letter sent to plaintiff and the other members of the class violated any provisions of the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (“the Act”), 15 U.S.C. § 1692

et seq.

Having carefully considered the arguments of counsel, the relevant statutory and case law and the record as a whole, the court issues the following order.

I. Undisputed Facts

In a letter dated June 25, 1993, defendant Credit Bureau of Athens, Inc. (“CBA”), through its agent defendant William, N. Slaughter, mailed a single letter to first-named plaintiff Schimmel seeking to collect several alleged debts totaling $320.00. Because of its centrality to the case, this letter, which has become known to the parties as “WNS-2” after Slaughter’s initials, is reprinted below in full.

*1360

[[Image here]]

(Complaint, Exh. A).

Slaughter is the majority shareholder of CBA with 52% of its stock. He is also the general manager of the company, and is the sole person in charge of overseeing its day to day operations. Slaughter’s brother owns the other 48% of CBA, but does not take an active role in managing the company, and in fact rarely visits the office. Slaughter also owns the building in which CBA is housed, and pays himself rent from CBA’s account for the lease.

Slaughter manages CBA from an office he maintains within the larger office area of CBA. He does not have a separate office out of which he practices law. Slaughter is not

*1361

listed in the phone book as an attorney at law; he receives phone calls through the CBA switchboard. All correspondence is received at the same address as that listed for CBA. Slaughter does not maintain computer or filing systems separate from those of CBA.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.