District Court, W.D. Virginia July 9, 1997, Criminal 97-6-H (United States v. Toliver)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-07-1997
OPINION AND ORDER
JONES, District Judge.
In this criminal case, the defendant, charged with one count of endeavoring to obstruct or impede the administration of the tax code and two counts of willfully making and subscribing a false tax return, has filed several pretrial motions. The defendant has moved for a dismissal of the obstruction count on several different grounds and for the dismissal of the entire indictment because each count is duplicitous. I deny the defendant’s motions. I will also deny the defendant’s request for a bill of particulars, and his request for the suppression of certain documents. I will reserve ruling on his motion to have language struck from the indietment until after the presentation of evidence at trial.
1
I. Background.
This case arises out of the defendant’s alleged failure to report to the Internal Revenue Service (“IRS”) taxable income obtained through his employer’s travel reimbursement plan and from his efforts to conceal this income. Between 1989 and 1994, the defendant, George T. Toliver (“Toliver”), was employed by the National Basketball Association (“NBA”) as a referee. Pursuant to the terms of each collective bargaining agreement (“CBA”) in effect between the NBA and the National Basketball Referees Association (“Union”), referees were furnished with first-class tickets or the cash value of these fares for flights longer than two hours. Under the CBAs, the referees had the right to downgrade these fares to lower priced tickets and to retain the difference. Under the internal revenue code, the retained amounts constituted taxable income.
Between 1989 and 1994, the IRS had different reporting and withholding requirements for income generated by an employer’s reimbursement plan. Prior to 1990, the IRS only required an employer to report such income. In the case of the defendant, for the 1990 tax year, the NBA issued a 1099 form reporting the entire amount of the first-class tickets provided to him.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit