District of Columbia Court of Appeals December 23, 1997, 95-CF-1145 (Jolly v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 23-12-1997
FARRELL, Associate Judge:
On this appeal from his convictions for felony murder while armed (robbery) and related offenses, Jolly’s primary argument is that repeated instructions to the jury by the trial judge unfairly limited his ability to demonstrate the bias of key government witnesses. The disputed instructions stemmed from the judge’s effort to draw a line between two defenses: (a) a legitimate bias defense that these witnesses had falsely accused Jolly to avert police suspicion from themselves (in the case of one witness) or another person close to them as the true murderer, and (b) what the judge determined was an unfounded theory that either of those two persons had in fact committed the crime. The distinction is a fine one because, to be believable, the bias defense presupposed that the witnesses had
reason
to fear the person they were protecting would be incriminated. Thus, the instruction the judge repeatedly gave reminding the jury that no evidence
in fact
linked the other persons to the crime potentially weakened a bias defense that the judge recognized as legitimate. The distinction the judge made is a settled one in our decisions, however, and after careful examination of the record we are convinced that his actions did not unfairly limit Jolly’s ability to argue the bias of the witnesses to the jury. We reject appellant’s remaining contentions as well, and therefore affirm.
I.
On August 8,1994, taxi driver Keith Moore was shot to death during a robbery at about 10:00 p.m. on Douglas Road, S.E. Witnesses placed appellant Jolly in the company of codefendant Dwayne Taylor
1
a half hour before the murder when Taylor phoned for a taxi and Moore responded in his cab to the Marlboro Plaza Apartments, where Jolly lived. A police officer working as a private security guard at the apartments saw Jolly
*858
(whom he knew) seated in the cab presumably with Taylor moments before the cab departed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit