United States Bankruptcy Court, D. Maine August 15, 1997, 14-10399 (Beesley v. Burke (In Re Beesley))

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-1997

MEMORANDUM OF DECISION

JAMES B. HAINES, Jr., Chief Judge.

Before me is Robert and Gail Beesley’s motion seeking an order compelling Karen M. Burke, Esq., their former Chapter 7 counsel, to disgorge fees. For the reasons set forth below, I will grant the motion. In addition, because Attorney Burke’s conduct raises substantial questions regarding her fitness to practice in'this court and regarding her billing practices for Chapter 7 debtors, I will order her to appear before me to show cause why additional sanctions should not be imposed.

1

Facts

1.

Case History

The Beesleys, contemplating bankruptcy, met with Attorney Burke in May 1996. On May 8 they paid her $750.00 to represent them in a Chapter 7 filing. On June 5 they paid her the $175.00 filing fee. On June 6 Attorney Burke filed their voluntary Chapter 7 petition.

*6

With the debtors’ petition, Attorney Burke filed the statement required by § 329(a)

2

and Rule 2016(b).

3

That statement is reproduced as Appendix A to this opinion. After unremarkable travel, the trustee filed a “no asset” report and the Beesleys received their discharge. The case was closed on November 25,1996.

On May 27, 1997, the Beesleys, represented by new . counsel, moved to reopen their case, alleging that Attorney Burke had charged them over $1,800.00 for services she had agreed to provide for $925.00,

4

that her fees were unreasonable, and that she had failed to file a supplemental Rule 2016(b) statement disclosing additional fees paid her before their bankruptcy ease closed. The Beesleys sought return of some or all of the money they had paid Attorney Burke, plus costs and fees.

I concluded that the Beesleys’ motion set forth facts that, if proved, would entitle them to relief and granted the motion to reopen on May 30, 1997.

See

§ 350(b). Attorney Burke, with counsel of her own, responded and, on June 27, 1997, filed a supplemental Rule 2016(b) statement disclosing that, in addition to the $925.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.