United States Bankruptcy Court, M.D. Alabama July 14, 1997, 17-30402 (In Re Bradley)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-07-1997
OPINION ON TRUSTEE’S OBJECTION TO EXEMPTION
A. POPE GORDON, Bankruptcy Judge.
The trustee filed an objection to the homestead exemption claimed by the debtors under Aim Code § 6-10-2(1975).
The trustee and the debtors submitted briefs on the objection following a hearing held March 18,1997.
The facts are substantially undisputed.
The debtors purchased a home in 1995 located at 5701 Hyde Park Drive, Montgomery, Alabama.
After purchasing the home, the debtors discovered termite damage which may have been affirmatively concealed by the sellers, the real estate agent, and others.
The debtors filed an action for damages for the alleged fraudulent concealment.
1
The debtors filed a petition under chapter 7 of the Bankruptcy Code on January 2, 1997.
2
The debtors claimed the cause of action exempt from property of the estate under the homestead exemption statute in the amount of $8,100.
3
The trustee contends that the cause of action is personal property and not subject to exemption under the homestead statute.
The trustee is correct that a cause of action constitutes personal property.
4
*999
However, the debtors rely on
Ellis v. Pratt City,
111 Ala 629, 20 So. 649 (1896), to claim the cause of action exempt under the homestead exemption statute.
Ellis
extended a municipal real property exemption to proceeds from an insurance policy covering fire damage to the city hall. The court held that the “proceeds of the policy, in case of loss, shall ... stand in the place of the property destroyed.”
5
The debtors contend that the cause of action in the instant case for fraudulent concealment of termite damage is analogous to the insurance claim in
Ellis
for damage caused by fire.
6
However,
Ellis
is not applicable to the facts in the instant ease because the debtors did not own the home when the termite damage occurred. The basis of the cause of action is the fraudulent concealment of termite damage which preexisted their ownership.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit