Supreme Court of Iowa May 21, 1997, 95-2137 (Sheeder v. Lemke)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-05-1997

CARTER, Justice.

Steven and Janet Sheeder, vendees under a contract of sale involving 160 acres of land, appeal from a decree upholding the forfeiture of their interest by the vendors, Carl and Shirley Lemke. After considering the arguments of counsel and reviewing the record de novo in this equity action, we conclude that the district court’s decree should be reversed

*2

and the forfeiture nullified subject to conditions that we impose.

I.

Factual Background.

This cause was tried in equity. We make the following findings of fact after our de novo review of the record. Iowa R.App. P. 4;

Goodale v. Bray,

546 N.W.2d 212, 214 (Iowa 1996).

In March 1992 the Sheeders purchased 160 acres in Guthrie County on contract from the Lemkes. The contract price was $143,000. No down payment was required. The Sheeders were given possession on April 1, 1992. Each March, beginning in 1993, they were to make payments of $5720 toward the principal owed, plus accrued interest. The Sheeders have made all payments in a timely fashion, except for a brief, partial delinquency of $2000 in 1994 that has since been cured. There remains unpaid principal on the contract price of roughly $126,000, plus accrued interest. Credible evidence indicates that the property was worth at least $170,000 at the time of the purported forfeiture.

When the Sheeders acquired the property, it was necessary to make substantial improvements to the dwelling house located there. The garage, corncrib, Harvestore silo, hog house, and two barns located on the property were also in fairly poor repair at the time the Sheeders purchased the property. The Sheeders replaced several broken and missing windows, recarpeted, refinished the house’s woodwork, replaced rotten drywall, and repaired a leaky roof. They installed a water heater and a water softener (the house had neither when the Sheeders purchased it). They replaced an old coal-burning furnace and a septic tank.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.