District Court, D. Rhode Island May 29, 1997, C.A. 94-0385B (Fratus v. Republic Western Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-05-1997
OPINION
FRANCIS J. BOYLE, Senior District Judge.
Plaintiffs bring this diversity action against defendant insurer to recover under six insurance policies issued by defendant.
Plaintiff Joseph Fratus was employed by the State of Rhode Island to control traffic about a road construction site on Interstate Route 295 in the City of Cranston. On June 4, 1985, a U-Haul truck operated by defendant Joseph T. Obert (“Obert”) was rented in Worcester, Massachusetts from U-Haul Co. of Western Massachusetts by Obert’s employer, American Drywall Company, Inc. (“Drywall”). Obert was to pick up construction materials in Rhode Island and return them to Massachusetts. The truck veered into the construction site striking plaintiff Joseph Fratus and another state employee. The injuries suffered by Fratus rendered him a paraplegic.
Plaintiffs brought a diversity action in this court against Drywall, Obert and a bevy of U-Haul companies. The U-Haul defendants included the following: U-Haul Co. of Western Massachusetts, a Massachusetts corporation, from whom the truck was leased; Amerco Lease Co., a Nevada corporation, which held title to the truck; and U-Haul Co. of Western Michigan, a Michigan corporation, the registered owner of the truck. Following jury verdicts, judgments were entered in favor of plaintiffs. The jury returned verdicts against Obert and Drywall, his employer, and awarded damages to Fratus, Stephanie L. Fratus, his wife, and Carissa M. Fratus, his daughter. The jury awards were substantial: $2,900,00 to Fratus; $20,000 to his wife; and $250,000 to his daughter. On December 14, 1988, judgments were entered on the jury verdicts. (Following the litigation described below, a further form of Judgment was entered on July 2, 1990.) The plaintiffs calculate that the verdicts plus pre-judgment interest amount to $4,100,600 for Fratus; $28,200 for his wife; and $353,500 for his daughter.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit