District Court, D. Oregon February 21, 1997, Civil 96-1649-MA (Schmid v. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan of the Northwest)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-02-1997

OPINION AND ORDER

MARSH, District Judge.

Plaintiff filed this action against defendants for breach of contract and negligence in the Circuit Court for the State of Oregon in Multnomah County. Defendant removed the complaint to federal court based on federal question jurisdiction under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), 29 U.S.C. §§ 1001 — 1461. Currently before the court is plaintiffs motion to remand to state court.

Plaintiff was a participant in a health care plan (“the Plan”) sponsored by her husband’s employer. Plaintiff suffered two conditions for which she sought medical treatment from a physician and a dentist at Kaiser Permanente; plaintiff names Kaiser Permanente, as well as the individual physician and a dentist as defendants. Plaintiff contends that defendant breached its contract in failing to provide, or providing sub-standard medical treatment. Specifically, plaintiff contends that defendant breached its contractual obligation of good faith and fair dealing in failing to properly diagnose and treat plaintiffs conditions, failing to provide certain tests and treatments, failing to properly perform the services which were provided, and in placing the financial interest of defendant Kaiser ahead of plaintiffs health and physical well being in determining whether to preauthorize, provide and agree to pay benefits for an open TMJ reduction and articular disk repair. Plaintiff alleges that these same acts and omissions constitute negligence, which she asserts against the individual doctor and dentist and against Kaiser Permanente on a vicarious liability theory.

Defendants removed the action to federal court on the grounds that plaintiffs claims are governed by ERISA, and thus federal question jurisdiction exists. Currently before the court is plaintiffs motion to remand this complaint to state court.

A state law claim may be preempted by ERISA in two ways. A claim “to recover benefits due ... under the terms of the plan, to enforce ...

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.