Kentucky Supreme Court June 19, 1997, 96-SC-0127-DG (Niehoff v. Surgidev Corp.)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-06-1997
combined-opinion
950 S.W.2d 816 (1997) Kathryn NIEHOFF, Appellant, v. SURGIDEV CORPORATION, Appellee. No. 96-SC-0127-DG. Supreme Court of Kentucky. June 19, 1997. Rehearing Denied October 2, 1997. *817 Roy Kimberly Snell, LaGrange, for Appellant. William Kennedy Simpson, Carol Dan Browning, Jeanne M. Picht, Stites and Harbison, Louisville, for Appellees. WINTERSHEIMER, Justice. This appeal is from a decision of the Court of Appeals which affirmed a summary judgment by the circuit court determining that the claim for compensatory and punitive damages was properly dismissed because federal law preempted any claim for state tort relief. The issue is whether the tort claim under Kentucky common law is in conflict with or divergence from any specific federal regulation applicable to the medical device which allegedly ultimately resulted in the loss of the patient's eye. Facts of this Case The product involved in this appeal is the Style 10 intraocular lens (IOL) manufactured by Surgidev. The IOL is an artificial lens which replaces the natural crystalline lens in the human eye following cataract surgery. It is a prescription medical device which is surgically implanted in the patient's eye in order to replace the diseased natural lens of the eye. The Style 10 was a particular type of IOL known as a "closed-loop anterior chamber" IOL because it was specifically designed for implantation in the anterior chamber of the eye which is the space between the cornea and the iris. The Style 10 lens was provided to physicians who were ophthalmologists and served as clinical investigators pursuant to an investigational device exemption which was granted by the Federal Food and Drug Administration in April of 1978. Niehoff, whose vision had been significantly impaired by cataracts, had a cataract removed from her left eye by her ophthalmologist, Dr. John Hafer, in September of 1983. Dr. Hafer used a surgical technique known as "extracapsular cataract extraction.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit