Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama August 22, 1997, 2960404 (Pearson v. City of Hoover)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-08-1997

706 So.2d 1251 (1997) Julene R. PEARSON v. CITY OF HOOVER. 2960404. Court of Civil Appeals of Alabama. August 22, 1997. Rehearing Denied September 26, 1997. Certiorari Denied December 12, 1997. *1252 David Cromwell Johnson and Calvin S. Rockefeller III of Johnson, Rosenthal, Liddon & Tuggle, Birmingham, for appellant. Jack H. Harrison, Hoover, for appellee. Alabama Supreme Court 1970047. PER CURIAM. Julene R. Pearson appeals from a summary judgment entered by the Jefferson County Circuit Court in favor of the City of Hoover on her appeal from an adverse decision of the City of Hoover Board of Zoning Adjustments (the "Board") on her request for a zoning variance. We reverse the summary judgment and render a judgment in favor of Pearson. Pearson owns property located in the City of Hoover. Her lot is a "through lot," which is defined as a lot that is bordered by two parallel streets; in Pearson's case, her lot is bordered by Summit Cove Road and Shades Crest Road. The front of Pearson's home faces Summit Cove Road. However, under an ordinance enacted by the City of Hoover, Pearson has two front yards; because her lot is a through lot, both yards of the lot are considered front yards. See Hoover City Code, Appendix I—Zoning, Art. VII, § 2.1(C). A Hoover city ordinance prohibits the erection of fences in front yards. Pearson applied to the Board for a variance from the operation of this ordinance, claiming that she needed to erect a fence to front Shades Crest Road because of the threat of burglaries, the existence of erosion from surface water, the potential liability to trespassers mistaking the rear of her lot for a vacant lot, and the dumping of debris, garbage, and trash on the rear of her lot. After the Board denied Pearson's request for a variance, she appealed to the trial court, seeking a de novo trial before a jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.