District Court, E.D. Michigan June 30, 1997, 93-CV-71495-DT (Prestige Casualty Co. v. Michigan Mutual Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 30-06-1997

OPINION AND ORDER REGARDING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND DETERMINATION OF PREJUDGMENT INTEREST

ROSEN, District Judge.

I.

INTRODUCTION

This matter arises from a dispute between Plaintiff Prestige Casualty Company (“Prestige”) and Defendant Michigan Mutual Insurance Company (“Michigan Mutual”) regarding prejudgment interest on an indemnification judgment in the Wayne County Circuit Court for an auto accident. The case came to this Court on diversity jurisdiction when Prestige filed a Declaratory Judgment Complaint against Michigan Mutual to establish their relative liabilities with respect to the indemnification judgment. Here, the Court determined that Michigan Mutual had to pay 2/3 of the judgment and that Prestige had to pay 1/3.

When this determination was effectively upheld on appeal to the Sixth Circuit, Michigan Mutual sent Prestige a check for its share of the liability, including prejudgment and post-judgment interest. Prestige rejected the check because it disagrees with the manner in which Michigan Mutual calculated the prejudgment interest.

Thus, this matter is before the Court on Prestige’s March 10, 1997 Motion for Entry of Judgment and Determination of Prejudgment Interest. Here, Prestige argues that it is entitled to prejudgment interest from the date on which its insured filed a third-party action against the Defendant’s insured in the underlying auto accident lawsuit. Alternatively, Prestige argues that the Court should award prejudgment interest from the date on which it settled its insured’s obligations with the auto accident plaintiff.

Michigan Mutual, however, contends that since Prestige was not a party to the auto accident lawsuit, it should neither be allowed to receive prejudgment interest from the date on which its insured filed a third-party complaint against Michigan Mutual’s insured, nor from the date on which Prestige settled its insured’s obligations with the auto accident plaintiff.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.