Michigan Court of Appeals April 29, 1997, Docket Nos. 177054, 177055, 177062, 177064, 177163, and 177164 (Detroit Edison Co. v. Public Service Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-04-1997

Per Curiam.

These six appeals arise from a January 21, 1994, decision of the Michigan Public Service Commission (psc) and the psc’s June 16, 1994, decision on rehearing in a general rate case initiated by Detroit Edison Company on July 1, 1992. PSC No. U-10102. Detroit Edison sought a rate increase, effective January 1, 1994, of about $82.5 million annually for 1994 through 1996. Detroit Edison asked for additional increases during the course of the proceeding. Numerous parties intervened. The PSC concluded that Detroit Edison’s rates should be reduced by $78,025,000. These appeals concern several aspects of the psc’s decision. There is considerable overlap in the arguments of the appellants, particularly concem

*373

ing the psc’s exercise of authority regarding a “demand-side management” (dsm) program requested by Detroit Edison.

The standard of review for PSC orders is narrow and well established. MCL 462.25; MSA 22.44 provides that all rates, fares, practices, and services prescribed by the PSC are presumed, prima facie, to be lawful and reasonable.

Michigan Consolidated Gas Co v Public Service Comm,

389 Mich 624; 209 NW2d 210 (1973);

Attorney General v Public Service Comm,

206 Mich App 290, 294; 520 NW2d 636 (1994). An appellant must show by “clear and satisfactory evidence” that the order of the PSC complained of is “unlawful or unreasonable.” MCL 462.26(8); MSA 22.45(8);

Michigan Consolidated Gas Co, supra

at 639;

CMS Energy Corp v Attorney General,

190 Mich App 220, 228; 475 NW2d 451 (1991);

Attorney General, supra

at 294. Courts should not substitute their judgment for that of the administrative agency on a factual issue and must defer to the psc’s administrative expertise. 206 Mich App 294; 190 Mich App 228.

The PSC is a creature of the Legislature, and its authority must be found in statutory enactments.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.