Supreme Court of Iowa April 23, 1997, 95-1887 (Ollinger v. Bennett)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-04-1997

McGIVERIN, Chief Justice.

This appeal requires us to determine whether the trial court properly quieted title to disputed property in the plaintiffs based on the theory of boundary by acquiescence. We must also decide whether the trial court erred in dismissing the defendants’ counterclaim for intentional infliction of emotional distress. Because we find no error in the trial court’s judgment, we affirm.

I.

Background facts and proceedings.

This controversy revolves around a strip of land near the record boundary between parcels now owned by plaintiffs Leo and Mildred Ollinger and defendants Steven and Marilyn Bennett.

*169

In June 1972 the OUingers bought a tract of land in Johnson County, Iowa. The legal description of the property as set forth in the warranty deed excluded a parcel of 1.006 acres which earlier had been conveyed to another party and then in April 1972 to LoweU Coburn, Jr.

From the time they purchased their respective properties in 1972, both the Olling-ers and Coburn treated an existing fence and a line of trees planted by Cobum as the western and northern boundaries of Cobum’s property, so that the land west of the fence and north of the tree line was maintained as part of the OUingers’ property. This configuration meant that 0.35 acre, or about one-third, of Cobum’s property was treated as the OUingers’ property. At present, the 01-lingers and Bennetts disagree as to ownership of this .35 acre, which hereafter wiU be referred to as the “disputed property.”

The OUingers made sharecropping arrangements with other persons for some of their property, including the land west of the fence and north of the tree line. At other times they rented the property to people who used it for pasturing cattle and horses. A corral was built west of the fence to accommodate renters who pastured horses on the disputed property. The OUingers planted trees on the disputed property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.