District Court, M.D. Pennsylvania August 18, 1997, Civil Action 86-0386 (Petruzzi's, Inc. v. Darling-Delaware Co., Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-08-1997

MEMORANDUM

VANASKIE, District Judge.

As the concluding aspect of a class action settlement that yielded a dollar recovery to class members of approximately $400,000, counsel for the plaintiff class (hereinafter referred to as “class counsel”) requests attorneys’ fees in the amount of $4.7 million. Class counsel justifies this request by asserting that the full benefit of the two settlement agreements to the class was $9.4 million, a sum that class counsel claims represents the settling defendants’ exposure under agreements that essentially accorded to class members 10% of their , documented sales to the settling defendants over a prescribed time frame.

1

Contending that the entire “settlement fund” encompasses the settling defendants’ agreement to pay fees over and above payments made to class members, and asserting that a fee -of one-third of the “settlement fund” would be reasonable, class counsel arrives at a full settlement “value” of $14.1 million. Class counsel thus seeks a fee of $4.7 million, or 50% of the hypothetical $9.4 million benefit to the class.

2

Defendant Darling, which is responsible under its settlement agreement for any fee award in excess of $1 million, agrees with class counsel that fees should be calculated on a percentage basis, but argues that the dollar multiplicand in the calculation should be the amount actually recovered by class members, $399,656.10, as opposed to the mathematically derived hypothetical “benefit” of $9.4 million. Under Darling’s approach, a fee of one-third of the actual recovery would result in class counsel receiving only $120,000 for a ten year old case in which class counsel estimates that hours expended multiplied by 1995 hourly rates approximate $2.9 million.

In short, class counsel asks that I award fees that are approximately 12 times the

*599

amount actually recovered by class members.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.