Indiana Court of Appeals June 17, 1997, 55A01-9703-CR-80 (Matney v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-06-1997

*1153

OPINION

ROBERTSON, Judge.

David E. Matney appeals his conviction, after a jury trial, of the theft of a package of cigarettes for which he received a three-year sentence. Matney raises three issues, none of which constitute reversible error.

FACTS

The facts in the light most favorable to the verdict reveal that Matney lifted a package of cigarettes from a display in a store and concealed them under his shirt. Matney went through the check-out lane without paying for the cigarettes. When confronted by the store manager, Matney exclaimed that he was not even out of the store yet. Matney offered the store manager fifty dollars and to clean the store with a toothbrush to forget about the incident. While being detained in the office at the rear of the store, Matney stated that he could not get caught. Also, Matney chewed the cellophane wrapper off the top of the package and told one of the store employees not to tell that he had done so. Additional facts are supplied as necessary.

I.

Instruction on Ind.Code S5-Jp3-Jp-lp(c)

Matney argues the trial court erred in instructing the jury as follows:

Evidence that a person concealed property displayed or offered for sale and removed the property from any place within the business premises at which it is ... displayed or offered to a point beyond that at which payment should be made, constitutes prima facie evidence of intent to deprive the owner of the property of its value or use, and that the person exerted unauthorized control over the property. The term conceal means to hide, secret, to keep out of sight or prevent the discovery of an item.

This instruction tracks the language of I.C. 35-43-4-4(c). At trial, Matney objected to the instruction “because this is going into the province of the jury, judging the facts.” The trial court defined the term “prima facie evidence” in its instructions as:

Evidence good and sufficient on its face.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.