California Court of Appeal December 5, 1997, B106201 (Pieper v. Commercial Underwriters Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-12-1997

Opinion

ALDRICH, J.

Introduction

Plaintiffs, cross-defendants, and appellants James Pieper and Jeanne Ellen Pieper (the Piepers) appeal from judgment entered in favor of defendant, cross-complainant and respondent Commercial Underwriters Insurance Company (CUI).

The action arose from the Old Topanga Canyon fire, which destroyed the Piepers’ collection of rare ceremonial masks. The Piepers filed a claim with CUI under their “all risks” policy. CUI denied coverage pursuant to a “brush fire” exclusion. The Piepers filed an action for breach of insurance contract and for bad faith contending that their loss was caused by the covered peril of arson. CUI cross-complained for declaratory relief contending the brush fire exclusion applied. The Piepers and CUI each brought motions for summary judgment. The trial court granted GUI’s motion and denied the Piepers’ motion, finding that the brush fire exclusion precluded recovery under the all risks policy.

The coverage issue raised by this appeal is whether the fire, which was caused by arson, was a covered risk or an excluded risk under the brush fire exclusion clause of the Piepers’ policy.

We find the exclusion clause was unambiguous and that the Old Topanga Canyon fire was a brush fire within the exclusion clause as a matter of law.

*1012

There are no triable issues regarding the proximate and efficient cause of the fire as set forth in

Sabella

v.

Wisler

(1963) 59 Cal.2d 21 [27 Cal.Rptr. 689, 377 P.2d 889], as the sole cause of the Piepers’ loss was the brush fire, not arson.

Judgment is affirmed.

Factual and Procedural Background

In May 1993, CUI issued the Piepers an all risks policy of insurance in the amount of $662,005 for their fine arts collection located in the Piepers’ home in Malibu. The Piepers owned one of the world’s rarest collections of ceremonial masks from Guatemala and Mexico and from the Pueblo Indians of the Southwest United States.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.