District Court, D. Colorado July 18, 1997, Civil Action 92-K-1040, (92-K-1994, 92-K-2368, 92-K-2441, 93-K-308, 95-K-1367) (Stat-Tech Liquidating Trust v. Fenster)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-07-1997

ORDER ON MAGISTRATE’S JUNE 9, 1997 RECOMMENDATION

KANE, Senior District Judge.

These related securities fraud cases are before me on various objections under Fed. R.Civ.P. 72(b) to the June 9, 1997 Recommendation of Magistrate Judge Pringle. The Magistrate Judge recommended,

inter alia,

that (1) Defendant Schneider Securities’ Resubmitted Motion for Summary Judgment in No. 92-K-1994 be granted as to Plaintiffs’ aiding and abetting claims under the Colorado Securities Act, but denied in all other respects; and (2) Defendant Hayden H. Thompson’s Motion for Summary Judgment in Nos. 92-K-1040, 92-K-1994 and 92-K-2441 be denied.

After careful review of the objections and responses thereto, as well as the briefs upon which the Recommendation was based, I sustain in part the objections of Defendant Hayden Thompson and the Plaintiffs in Nos. 92-K-1040, 92-K-1994 and 92-K-2441 and overrule the objections of Schneider Securities in No. 92-K-1994. With the modifications explained below, I adopt the Recommendation of the Magistrate Judge as an order of the court for the reasons stated therein.

I.

Defendant Thompson’s Objections.

In his June 9 order, the Magistrate Judge recommended that Defendant Thompson’s motion for summary judgment on the Trust’s claims in 92-K-1040, the claims of VBW/ TRW in 92-K-1994 and the Proactive Plaintiffs in 92-K-2441 be denied. The Magistrate Judge found sufficient evidence of

scienter

in the record to support the state and federal securities fraud claims of Stat-Tech, Proactive and VBW against Thompson, but found the Trust had failed to adduce sufficient evidence of reliance to withstand summary judgment on its claim for damages based on Defendants’ alleged violations of the federal securities laws. Based on a perceived distinction between Colorado and federal securities law after

Rosenthal v. Dean Witter Reynolds, Inc.,

908 P.2d 1095 (Colo.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.