Supreme Court of Vermont November 17, 1997, 96-526 (State v. Fredette)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1997

The State appeals the district court’s interlocutory order suppressing the results of defendant’s breath test in a prosecution for driving while intoxicated (DWI), third offense. The trial court suppressed the test on the grounds that the arresting officer incorrectly informed defendant’s attorney that defendant had only one prior DWI conviction. We reverse.

During the evening of February 8, 1996, a state trooper responding to a report of a one-car accident found defendant lying injured inside his overturned car. The officer noticed the smell of alcohol at the scene, and the dispatcher informed him that defendant had a prior record of motor vehicle violations. At trial, the officer testified that he did not recall learning any specifics about defendant’s prior record from the dispatcher, but he recalled defendant stating that he had an extensive prior history of motor vehicle violations. Defendant was transported to a hospital, where he voluntarily submitted to a preliminary alcosensor screening test that yielded a result in excess of the legal limit. The officer then informed defendant that he intended to process him for DWI. After being read his rights, defendant asked to speak to an attorney. The officer telephoned the public defender on call that evening.

The public defender testified at trial that she had no memory of her telephone call with defendant, but her notes on a preprinted form admitted into evidence indicated that the officer told her that defendant had one prior DWI conviction. After speaking to the public defender, the officer turned the telephone over to defendant and left his hospital room. The attorney and defendant consulted in private by telephone for several minutes. According to the attorney’s notes, defendant told her that he had an 8-year-old DWI conviction, that he had not been drinking, and that he wanted to take a breath test. In light of the information provided to her, the public defender recommended that defendant take the test.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.