Texas Court of Appeals, 14th District (Houston) November 13, 1997, 14-96-00947-CV (Mulligan v. Beverly Enterprises-Texas Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-11-1997

OPINION

ANDERSON, Justice.

This is a case of alleged nursing home malpractice brought under the Deceptive Trade Practiees-Consumer Protection Act [DTPA]. Nancy Mulligan [Mulligan] appeals from a take nothing judgment granted in favor of Beverly Enterprises-Texas, Inc. D/B/A Leisure Lodge Nursing Home and Healthcare Centers of Texas, Inc. D/B/A Anahuac Healthcare. Mulligan initially filed suit against the nursing home owners claiming both negligence and violations of the DTPA. However, the negligence claim was ultimately dropped and the DTPA claim alone went to trial. A directed verdict was subsequently entered against Mulligan.

On appeal, Mulligan brings four points of error. Mulligan contends the trial court erred in entering a directed verdict because (1) her pleadings were sufficient as a matter

*882

of law to support a judgment, (2) the appel-lees offered no evidence conclusively proving a fact establishing the right to a judgment as a matter of law, (3) the appellants offered evidence of probative force on each DTPA claim sufficient to raise an issue of fact on the material questions, and (4) testimony from two fact witnesses offering evidence on material questions was improperly excluded. We affirm.

In January of 1990, Nancy Mulligan began touring nursing homes in anticipation of moving her aunt, Madeline Smith, into one of the facilities. After investigating several nursing homes, she selected the Leisure Lodge Nursing Home in Anahauc.

1

Mulligan allegedly placed Madeline Smith at Leisure Lodge after talking with the facility administrator and personally touring the nursing home. During discussions with the nursing home, Mulligan received several advertising brochures detailing the services Leisure Lodge provided its residents. Madeline Smith remained a resident at Leisure Lodge until her transfer to Cleveland Regional hospital where she died in 1994.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.