Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit April 4, 1997, 95-4153 (Angela Johnson v. Larry Methorst)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-04-1997

United States Court of Appeals

FOR THE EIGHTH CIRCUIT

___________

No. 95-4153

___________

Angela Johnson, *

*

Appellant, * Appeal from the United States

* District Court for the District

v. * of North Dakota.

*

Larry Methorst, *

*

Appellee. *

___________

Submitted: October 23, 1996

Filed: April 4, 1997

___________

Before MAGILL, BRIGHT and MURPHY, Circuit Judges.

___________

BRIGHT, Circuit Judge.

Angela Johnson brought this civil action against Larry Methorst for

bodily injuries sustained in a motor vehicle accident. The jury awarded

Johnson damages of $54,435, including $9,935 for past medical expenses and

$30,000 for future medical expenses. The magistrate judge reduced the

award for past medical expenses by $9,935 and the award for future medical

expenses by $20,065, thereby reducing the award by a total of $30,000,

representing the full amount of Methorst’s no-fault insurance benefits.

Johnson appeals the reduction of the award for future medical expenses.

We reverse and remand.

I. BACKGROUND

On June 7, 1992, while driving a motor vehicle, Methorst struck

Johnson, a pedestrian, injuring her knee and back. Alleging diversity

jurisdiction, Johnson brought a tort action for past and future damages in

federal court. Methorst admitted liability but disputed the nature and

extent of Johnson’s injuries. Specifically, he claimed that Johnson’s

physical injuries pre-existed the accident. The jury awarded Johnson

damages of $54,435 as follows:

a. Past medical expenses $ 9,935

b. Past pain, discomfort, mental

anguish and/or permanent disability 1,000

c. Past loss of productive time 0

d. Future medical expenses 30,000

e. Future pain, discomfort, mental

anguish and/or permanent disability 6,000

f. Future loss of productive time 7,500

The court initially entered a judgment for $54,435, but then reduced

the award by $9,935 for Johnson’s past medical expenses because Methorst’s

no-fault insurance carrier already reimbursed or was about to reimburse

Johnson for those costs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.