Ohio Court of Appeals November 13, 1997, No. 97APE06-816. (Community Advocate, Inc. v. Ohio Elections Commission)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-11-1997

Tyack, Presiding Judge.

On December 13, 1995, Lonnie W. Lewis, a candidate for Indian Springs, Ohio/Fairfield Township trustee in the November 1995 election, filed a complaint with the Ohio Elections Commission (“OEC”) against Community Advocate, Inc. (“Community Advocate”) and Joseph P. Ebbing. Lewis alleged that Community Advocate and Ebbing violated R.C. 3599.03, which prohibits corporations from engaging in certain political activity. Specifically, Lewis took issue with certain statements made in one of Community Advocate’s newsletters that urged people not to vote for him.

Community Advocate, a nonprofit corporation, and Ebbing, its incorporator and statutory agent, responded with a motion to dismiss, contending that R.C. 3599.03, as applied to them, is unconstitutional. On August 23, 1996, the OEC mailed its decision, finding that Community Advocate and Ebbing had violated R.C. 3599.03 and imposing a $100 fine.

Community Advocate and Ebbing appealed the decision to the Franklin County Court of Common Pleas. On June 3, 1997, the common pleas court rendered its decision, finding that R.C. 3599.03 was constitutional, and that the OEC had the authority to impose a fine. A judgment entry concluding that the OEC’s decision was supported by reliable, probative and substantial evidence and was in accordance with law was journalized on June 3, 1997. Community Advocate and Ebbing (collectively, “appellants”) have appealed to this court, assigning three errors for our consideration:

“Assignment of Error No. 1

“The Trial Court erred in holding that R.C. § 3599.03(A) and (B), as applied to Appellant’s, do not violate Appellants’ rights to free speech and association guaranteed under the United States and Ohio Constitutions.

*72

“Assignment of Error No. 2

“The Trial Court erred in holding that R.C. § 3599.03(B) is not unconstitutionally vague or overbroad.

“Assignment of Error No.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.