District of Columbia Court of Appeals December 4, 1997, Nos. 94-CF-579, 94-CO-1572, 96-CO-768 and 97-CO-728 (Boyd v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-12-1997

SCHWELB, Associate Judge:

On April 5, 1994, Anthony Boyd entered a plea of guilty to both counts of a two-count indictment charging him with distribution of heroin and with possession of heroin with intent to distribute it (PWID), in violation of D.C.Code § 33-541(a)(l) (1993). He was sentenced to serve two concurrent terms of imprisonment for from ten to thirty years, with each sentence including a ten-year mandatory minimum. The trial judge ordered that the two concurrent terms be served consecutively to any other sentence.1

On direct appeal from his convictions,2 Boyd contends, inter alia, that the trial judge participated in plea negotiations in violation of Super Ct.Crim. R. 11(e)(1), and that the judge’s intervention induced Boyd’s plea of guilty. Although the ease is a close one, we conclude that Rule 11 was violated and that the violation affected Boyd’s substantial rights. Accordingly, we reverse.

I.

THE TRIAL COURT PROCEEDINGS

Boyd and his eodefendant, Steven Barge, were arrested on June 2, 1993 and charged with distribution and PWID. The distribution charge arose from the sale by Barge to an undercover police officer of heroin which Boyd was orally advertising by its street brand name. The PWID charge was based on the recovery by the police of a bag which Barge dropped to the ground before his arrest, and which was found to contain heroin.

Boyd and Barge were indicted by a grand jury on June 17, 1993, and their case was subsequently assigned to a master drug calendar. A defendant who is so assigned has an opportunity to negotiate a plea bargain only until he receives a “final” plea offer from the prosecution. If he declines that offer, then no further plea offer is extended, and the case is reassigned from the master calendar to a trial calendar.

In conformity with master drug calendar procedures, the government extended plea offers to both Boyd and Barge.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.