Missouri Court of Appeals April 29, 1997, No. WD 53278 (Hubbert v. Boatmen's Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-04-1997

SMART, Judge.

Edna Hubbert appeals a final award of the Labor and Industrial Relations Commission (“Commission”) denying her Workers’ Compensation benefits. Ms. Hubbert claims that the Commission erred in determining that she was not entitled to benefits. Because we hold that the determination of the Commission was supported by sufficient competent evidence and was not against the overwhelming weight of the evidence, we affirm.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Ms. Hubbert worked at Boatmen’s Bank as a keypunch operator. She began work at Boatmen’s Bank in 1967. Initially, Ms. Hub-bert worked in the check processing department operating a Bank Tech machine. Her job required that she perform many repetitive tasks. Ms. Hubbert later went to work in the balancing department at the bank. Her work in that department also involved performing many repetitive tasks.

In January or February of 1989, Ms. Hub-bert’s right hand started to bother her. She told Marla Kimsey, her department supervisor, that she was having trouble with her hands in that she was beginning to lose her grip and have some swelling. She did not mention that she believed that the pain in her hand was work-related. Ms. Hubbert went to see her family doctor in March 1989. He sent her to a specialist. Eventually, she was referred to Dr. Gary L. Porubsky. Dr. Porubsky is board certified in orthopaedic surgery, and has earned a certificate of qualification for hand surgery.

Dr. Porubsky first examined Ms. Hubbert on September 27,1989. X-rays taken of Ms. Hubbert’s left wrist revealed an ulnar minus variant, meaning that the ulna is shorter than the radius. An ulna minus variant, a congenital condition, is considered normal in approximately 23% of the population. In examining x-rays of Ms. Hubbert’s right wrist, Dr. Porubsky discovered that she had Stage 3 Kienbock’s disease. Kienbock’s is a disease process involving the carpal bones, especially the lunate bone, in which there is a loss of blood supply.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.