Missouri Court of Appeals June 3, 1997, Nos. 69963, 69964, 69965 (Aboussie v. Chicago Title Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-06-1997

CRAHAN, Presiding Judge.

Condominium purchasers and title insurance carriers cross appeal following entry of judgment in favor of selected purchasers on their breach of contract claims, judgment notwithstanding the verdict on their negligence claims and award of a new trial as to damages only for the remaining purchasers. We modify the judgment to reinstate the award of damages for breach of contract in favor of those purchasers who sold their property prior to judgment, affirm the judgment notwithstanding the verdict on purchasers’ negligence claims and reverse the award of a new trial.

Plaintiffs are all purchasers of one or more condominium units in a development originally called Breckenridge on the Lake, now known as the Mariana Bay Condominiums, a hotel condominium complex located at the Lake of the Ozarks. All of the Plaintiffs obtained title insurance from Chicago Title Insurance Company, Ticor Title Insurance Company, or Ticor’s predecessor, Pioneer National Insurance Company. At the time of Plaintiffs’ purchases, the condominium declaration included what was known as the Old Recreation Building as a common area of the complex. The condominium developer, however, did not own the Old Recreation Building at the time it was originally included in the declaration.

The developer eventually acquired the Old Recreation Building in December, 1980. Later, through a series of transactions, the developer attempted to withdraw the Old Recreation Building from the declaration and to transfer it to other individuals or entities. Title to the Old Recreation Building eventually ended up in the hands of an entity known as BOTL Management in 1987. In amending the declaration, however, the developer failed to obtain the written consent of all existing unit owners as required by the declaration for withdrawal of common elements.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.